Now Offering Mental Wellness Visits!
Search
Close this search box.

Now Offering Mental Wellness Visits!

Responsive, Not Responsible: A New Approach to Leadership for High Achievers

July 3, 2025
leadership
If you’re a high-performing perfectionist, you’ve probably been praised for your reliability, your drive, your ability to get things done. But these same strengths can quietly pull you into patterns of over-responsibility, burnout, and reactive leadership. Responsive Leadership offers a counter-narrative—a mindset rooted in clarity, boundaries, and flexibility. It helps leaders stay engaged and effective without falling into the trap of believing they have to do it all.

Top Three Lessons about Responsive Leadership

  1. You’re not responsible for everything—clarity and boundaries make you a stronger leader.
    Perfectionists often default to over-functioning. Responsive Leadership invites you to pause and ask: What am I actually responsible for? What am I simply responding to? This shift lightens the mental load and sharpens your leadership impact.
  2. Saying ‘no’ or ‘not now’ is not a failure—it’s a leadership skill.
    Many high achievers fear that saying no will make them seem weak or unhelpful. But setting boundaries protects your (and your team’s) energy and ensures you’re directing it where it matters most. Responsive Leadership treats boundary-setting as strategic, not selfish.
  3. You don’t have to choose between compassion and effectiveness.
    Responsive Leadership helps you hold complexity—to be both emotionally intelligent and clear, both caring and candid. When you stop trying to do it all perfectly, you make space for something better: leadership that’s both human and impactful.

 

Why Responsive Leadership?

When you’re wired for excellence, it’s easy to fall into the belief that success means overextending yourself. You might feel responsible for outcomes that are outside your control, or over-involved in things that others could be handling. This creates a pattern of exhaustion, micromanagement, and even resentment.

Responsive Leadership changes that. It centers the question: What requires my full presence—and what doesn’t? It helps you lead from a place of responsiveness, not reactivity, and makes space for more thoughtful, sustainable action.

 

Seven Core Skills of Responsive Leadership

  1. Clarity
    Know and communicate what’s yours to own—and what isn’t. Clarity is also about your role, and about the system you work within- more role clarity and systems clarity help you know the frame around your work.
  2. Saying ‘No’
    Respect your capacity by choosing where you invest your time. “Not right now” can be a powerful leadership move.
  3. Strategic Thinking
    Instead of reacting to what’s urgent, think about what’s important—and why.
  4. Frankness
    Be honest, even when it’s uncomfortable. Frankness is a range of communication approaches that creates direction, not confusion.
  5. Emotional Intelligence
    Understand your emotional responses and stay attuned to others without becoming consumed by them.
  6. Recognizing Positive Outcomes
    Stop and name what’s working. This builds momentum and trust. It also invites in opportunities for greater cohesion of your team.
  7. Managing Your Own Discomfort
    Practice staying steady in the face of tension, conflict, or ambiguity. Leadership gets real here and is a place to use the skills you’ve developed around emotional regulation.

 

“Let People Cook”

A core principle in Responsive Leadership is this: Don’t do for others what they can do for themselves. High-performing perfectionists often take over tasks, fix problems, or jump in to prevent mistakes. But that’s not leadership—it’s over-functioning.

Trusting others to “cook” (solve, act, decide) builds their confidence and your capacity. It also deepens accountability across the team or system.

 

Practice the Pause

Responsive Leadership is about responding with intention—not reacting out of urgency, guilt, or perfectionism.

The next time someone makes a request that feels overwhelming or unclear, pause and ask:

  • Why does this feel heavy or complicated?
  • What’s really being asked?
  • Can I respond to the “why” without owning the whole “what”?

 

That pause is where Responsive Leadership lives.

 

Making the Shift: Three Steps to Start

  1. Assess Your Leadership Patterns
    Notice where you tend to over-own, avoid discomfort, or default to yes. That’s your map. This step is a great time to engage with a coach to build your ability to notice and assess.
  2. Practice One Skill at a Time
    Choose one Responsive Leadership skill (like saying no or naming success) and experiment with it this week.
  3. Get Support
    Work with a coach, therapist, or trusted colleague to practice new ways of thinking and leading. This is especially helpful if perfectionism is hardwired into your professional identity.

 

You Don’t Have to Lead Alone—or Perfectly

Responsive Leadership helps you show up fully without burning out. It replaces unrealistic expectations with grounded presence. And it opens up space for teams, organizations, and people to grow together—without anyone having to carry it all.

 

Self-Reflection

For the perfectionist in the room, if your inner critic says you must do everything right or you’ll let people down, Responsive Leadership offers an alternative. It doesn’t lower the bar—it refocuses it.

Try asking yourself:

  • Where am I confusing being helpful with being over-responsible?
  • Am I trying to solve a problem that isn’t actually mine?
  • What outcome am I trying to control—and what would happen if I stepped back?
  • What is one Responsive Leadership skill you can choose and practice with intention this week?
Resources
  • “The Hard Skills” Podcast: How Responsive Leadership Offers a New Way to Navigate Complexity (2024) with Mira Brancu, PhD and Traci Callandrillo, PhD. Learn more about the guiding principles of Responsive Leadership including the seven core values and seven essential skills to approach leadership through a stance of being responsive to rather than taking responsibility for in your work.
  • Cross, R., Rebele, R., & Grant, A. (2016). Collaborative Overload. Harvard Business Review, 94, 74–79.  https://hbr.org/2016/01/collaborative-overload An excellent article for high achievers who feel overwhelmed by helping everyone all the time.
  • Bindl, U. K., Parker, S. K., Sonnentag, S., & Stride, C. B. (2022). Managing your feelings at work, for a reason: The role of individual motives in affect regulation for performance-related outcomes at work. Journal of Organizational Behavior, 43(7), 1251-1270.  https://doi.org/10.1002/job.2628
  • Orkibi, H., & Brandt, Y. I. (2015). How Positivity Links With Job Satisfaction: Preliminary Findings on the Mediating Role of Work-Life Balance. Europe’s journal of psychology11(3), 406–418. https://doi.org/10.5964/ejop.v11i3.869